casino online klubnik avtomati intermediate java tutorial buckys casino casino fauriel saint etienne psg 3d slotfather slots card reader for macbook pro slots jacy and kacythe cupcake roulette challenge r2c casino saint etienne cathedral playboy games for android caesars atlantic city total rewards hoe winnen van roulette casino casino gambling gaming casino interviews for housekeepers casino creek little shelton casino croupier wage chiavi universali slots russisches roulette tater tot hotdish odataqueryoptions to linq casino casino room deals in ac toads kill goldfish casino online promotions usa online casino casino casnio gambling type roulette gaetano morgano casino the witches cauldron money rain casino game wales england rugby kasino meninggal umur berapa mn casino map mt rose ski resort reno poker games real money headies award 2015 winners video slots mbs casino hotline lyrics greyhound tracks in usa free downloadable slot games machines a sous gratuites casino sans telechargement viber todays rugby league results biggest lottery winner usa mayra isela chavez rueda de casino eskeleto nacho libre best free slot machines casino gambling in john travolta alien dc comics games online free bruce lee games golden emperor slots rosiki roulette lyrics bon casino near me virgin short haul slots www maxi slots com fife belterra casino shorter casino news gothensee klinik heringsdorf casino okean rush casino online rihanna russian roulette cover by anna khokhlova sep 08 2012 fantastic 4 video game zeus slot machine game xinh xinh cafe menu 80542 avenida santa eugenia indio casino things to see in reno racing results sky sports ojczym 2009 cda casino europa league format dubai ladies masters free on line slots mikroelektronika maser slots casino game slots oranjehof ouetehuis upington casino vagonetas no casino game casino europe bad gastein play free penny slot machines casino breda entree gold kustermannpark kasino bass game slot machine easter egg hunt games online free walton sports shop casino cosmopol sundsvall julbord online casino rtg bonus code blogs royal casino codes air force reserve pilot slots price is right play at home technique infallible roulette salsa casino caracas academias militares latest casino gambling forums big fish casino promo code 2014 casino east sussex party pooper slot machine online comics historietas viejas casino bet on superbowl neopets black pawkeet slots jackpot casino gratis jocuri online playmillion casino 10 euro cents firerock casino skinwalker academia salsa casino quimbara lyrics 68t mos slots casino vs taxi driver andreas fire rock casino casino estoril teatro casino ex drug dealer track lists 1001 online real money blackjack casino age nj real vegas slots online booker s backyard elgin il casino mignonette sauce recipe for oysters casino capri isle casino scotland vs australia rugby doa video game magic casino greyhound racing fixtures today geant casino andernos cinema casino island to go online game casino dealer requirements pa nickels gold nugget slots machines stronghold 3 gameplay online casino live footy online kasino ettlingen rheinland gray line nashville casino depot schedule x79 matx 8 dimm slots make real money playing games online clams casino mixtape 2 datpiff instrumentals spin n win canon 5d mark 3 dual card slots basketball in french english golf players juego dados casino river spirit casino logos jouer casino 770 gratuitement play slots online for fun racing post cheltenham quinault casino expansion in cleveland world cup squad rihanna take russian roulette lyrics tsunami wizard of oz ruby red slippers slots games echo vision burn card casino casino la ciotat ceyreste map casino vs japan go hawaii activities aria casino hosts toucan bar and grill ben affleck gambling casino conrad lyrics ben william hill daily millions brawa v100 007 casino casino kampnagel parken zoo xavier 007 casino teens young lesbian in the casino best way win casino craps cratos casino casino e netdemogamegarage runescape number of 99 slots scx digital slots casino 13 com jeux casino gratuit en ligne machine a sous title odds premier league jay leno grand casino mille lacs gourmet buffet and grill free games casino located in oakdale la figura de salsa casino 84 pa buffets in vegas cheap casino comment extras com games casino leave link casino casino gambling online online roulette yourbestonlinecasino com open hall decoration with a casino casino en ligne agree arjele how to deal blackjack obanions casino shopping mall near tulalip casino rugby union latest casino bristol va casino hry na stiahnutie do pcs casino altmark kaserne bad mass appeal rhythm roulette mannie fresh leaves casino la chabacana guadalajara mexican online casino free play top free casino games foster family services jackson casino emanuele casino pentitox free slot for fun russian roulette essie swatch nail casino junkets from grand rapids mi 2016 us presidential election ft gibson ok casino american star casino in vicksburg ms casinos russian roulette game realm grand slots george casinos that accept paypal dark haired pin up girl two front slots on coveralls fall river casino ma salsa rueda de casino moves like jabba scottish junior football association the best game online free fire games king of the titans river nile casino spyware doctor play slots for money with paypal casino barberey saint sulpice vang trang khoc news 41 battle creek mi casino southwind casino players club ricos bar and grill manistee mi casino play hearts of vegas betting on us open golf pokemon yellow slots prizes 00 roulette odds rapid roulette decisions per hour casino machine a sous gratuites sans telechargement viber mk4 six slots zone chat roulette sites opera house casino ukraine casino horse racing handicapping contests bill brownlee casino casino slots background symm slots carl henrik langebaek rueda de casino habbo casino names for dogs full tilt us casino arcade santa cruz hours ignition casino withdrawal champion hurdle cheltenham casino big win casino news masters snooker final borderlands pre sequel gameplaypch slots hee haw slot spielgeld casino lobby index belle vue tips casino mendrisio offerte lavoro ticino mode des annees folles casino casino game technician oscar casino casino con scaletta sand palm casino mayfair free strip poker game online games free fun woodbine slots package online casino bonuses uk athletics olg casino odds lui hibiki character item slots online casino finder com free money playing games casino directory gambling news online online casino doi thuong ngon frankie laine rawhide video slots russian roulette balloon gun ukc downpour band alton il casino maaninka kasino igre pearl river casino ms play deck the halls slots roller patins a roulette gratis entree holland casino utrecht liverpool 1 arsenal 2 something wicked time slots booking lco casino and lodge in hayward wi casino on net for phantom efx reel deal slots gods of olympus winter olympics skeleton sky channel 863 chinese new year games irish league cup play slots online for prizes russian roulette alex rider epub gratis casino vip jfkpc pig woman of sparta hoyle casino games patch ohio gambling laws asus xonar dx pci express x16 slots cheltnham gold cup casino soul orchestra do i love you snooker results today 3 dice casino software hoyle bob hope drive casino world of warcraft item id slots best odds video poker aladdin casino 333 casino net 888 slingo royale slots wild horses casino casino luc sur mer spectacled what odds are better play crapless craps online free academia salsa casino t posts jaylord casino twitter the aviator casino delano ca two girls play blowjob roulette winner gets a mouthful of jizz filesonic dragon story gold dragon interactive free games 31457 medinah hayward casino harry potter by joan roulette casino royal colgems casino auxonne dijon horaires rer manchester united vs tottenham 5 2 numero casino capvern bonus deuces wild strategy oldest board game in the world what are your odds of winning at a casino what is casino rate mega fun casino wilhelmshaven refinery czarownice serial cda casino free wolf games online couerderlane casino bridesmaids movie free online a0b5 casino ess casino credit clerk pay scale prinzessin spielen online blackjack casino rooms rochester stabbing casino aix drivers pelex doo casino casino pier asbury park nj www royal casino zagreb com casino bar mitzvah theme code bonus sans depot euroking casino rake at commerce casino trump casino tier points casino cruise myrtle beach fun online gmes scottish cup winners geant casino arbent oyonnax toulon rugby league latest score sunray park and casino winners www casino by casino enjoy chiloe national park kultur casino bern saalplan neue online gambling in washington state selena isleta casino casino 1995 audio latino online fun games for money the big chip list bloomington il casino surinaams feestje holland casino allereerste casino lol 8 item slots in wow casino buenos aires s and p wonka factory real bublichki lyrics russian roulette squad game russian roulette royal casino kathmandu geant casino noumea revenge online free arsen roulette discography procedure haftbefehl russisch roulette playlist 2016 slots real money 5 arrested casino slut chat roulette check pci slots pc pracon slots vegas slots 777 chelsea liverpool score today snooker blackpool 2014 nfl weather conditions motor racing terms nona s ice cream eureka casino best betting offers living in carlisle lifewater international slots cory aronovitz the casino law group geant casino nimes 1 mai mamaia boxing results mayweather juegos de casino tragamonedas para jugar gratis casino charbonniere teneues mermaids casino casino style salsa steps left succinic semialdehyde casino how to tumble bitcoins casino versus japan go hawaii blogspot coerd a lene casino dumb and dumber movie online kiss band video 777 slots apkhere pessoa bugada casino casino com x gilberto e gilmar mp3 players casino blotzheim accueille konami slot machines online juniper casino gold horse racing betting sites uk 7 lucky dwarfs slots online big brother dogface roku 3 microsd slots 510s hit it rich casino slots casino lily bittorrent best of video poker casino near wellsboro pa online casino mit 200 bonus stephanie barajas hawkins red hawk casino open online casino royal ace casino online bonus codes soft casino v 1 3 premium catecholborane casino best payout slot machines clams casino im god death grips lyrics portland spa resort royal jockey club uk casino play wheel of fortune slots russian roulette mark wahlberg casino jack 2010 xvid stb neosignal podcast 007 casino real casino slots free grand national sweep kit about casino gambling fantastic four emblem aqueduct casino crime family shareware roulette casino divonne horaires douverture lidl usa casinos online no deposit bonus heart of las vegas fiesta de 15 tipo casino casino vaisselle villeroy casino near orlando steam roulette heroku app china super league play single line slots www riverbelle casino casino caribe centro casino lons le saunier emeraude plage boat race odds ladbrokes casino casino angels camp carlotta cossutta casino both teams to score and win chimista slots anja schneider la roulette mp3 tdu2 casino online dlc certification las vegas tips and secrets reno google maps salisbury races tips casino nights west yorkshire grachi po polsku cda casino clams casino asap rocky lyrics about rita mac center eureka casino the price is right game free shift 2 gameplaypch slots york sports shops nudist las vegas celebrity hotel and casino deadwood sd simpsons slots turning stone casino fitness club casino blackjack tutorial video http doubledown casino code share venetain casino casino gratis senza soldi cheap roulette vegas rivers casino des plaines new years eve 2013 roger wagner casino casino jack and the united states of money trailer brake superman slot machine casino joe ashkar fostan kahneeta casino fire las vegas parking big win casino mod apk coc booking time slots drupal 7 wysiwyg sinio top 20 lines slots casino race resina olot slots vagalume mc guime lar doce lar casino the championship rugby casino de aranjuez actuaciones de elegidos vol zirconium kroon casino daehyun card roulette casino enghien les bains horaire douverture de la casino disegno da casino jeux saint raphael gra casino na telefon chomikuj royal casino mandelieu cabaret seoul korea airports russian roulette traduttore google van alstine super pas 4i slots hall green stadium casino in madrid clams casino bookfiend sharebeast casino pavia cabin fever game bill burton casino gambling fichas casino la toja dzekson what states have casinos game king slots software casino caliente tijuana revolucion how to win the money game real money casino online watch casino 1995 hd low rider comprar ruleta de casino profesional al capones casino casino boat in indiana casino gaming industry news monday football results gqoyeni lodge umfolozi casino arcade games center casino grand luxe retrait xs the nightclub at encore mbari ya hit it rich casino slots 1375 eagle rd elgin il casino alchemy free game trump taj mahal casino resort casino poole clams casino brookfield lyrics to hallelujah download puppy games casino xanthi copa del rey baloncesto american express onlinne slots epsom downs racing results wiz khalifa paper bond song casino what does surrender mean in blackjack spin the wheel of fortune black jack dealing More on the Book of David (Roodman) | .rupert
FINCA - Building tomorrow together

A Congolese Village Bank in Lumbumbashi

I’m back from a regional meeting of FINCA Africa in Lumbumbashi (say it with me), Democratic Republic of the Congo, during which I was able to meet and interview about a dozen clients. Stay tuned for a posting of this, hopefully next week.

In the meantime, I want to return to my critique of David Roodman’s “Due Diligence”, and thank him for his response which you may find on David Roodman’s Open Blog on Microfinance Wid all due respect, as Tony Soprano would say, I remain unconvinced of David’s conclusion that the impact on global poverty of my 40 year career in microfinance has been zero. It is as if I had never lived! Now, I was of course foolhardy to try to engage David — a econometric Goliath – on his own terrain. I recall the precise moment, as a Master’s Degree candidate at the U of Wisconsin, when I realized the statistical life was not for me. It was Euler’s Theorum that did me in. I canvassed the campus in vain for someone who could explain to me, in plain English, what was meant by “For homogenous functions there is a definite relationship between the values of the function and the values of its partial derivatives.” Cool! But, like, can you use that to launch a rocket? So I guess at this point the only way I will get my Doctorate is if some university bestows an Honorary Degree on me. (Any takers? No?) But not to beat a Hypothetical Horse, I think David, in his faith in the power of numbers, has strayed too far from the path of Common Sense. Example: If, as David concludes, there is value to be found in the creation of an industry that has corrrected — for many millions of people — the “market failure” of financial systems in Developing Countries, is it logical to then conclude that the impact on global poverty of this gargantuan investment has been zero?
Are we to believe that joining millions of people who earn their living each day in the informal sector, and who previously had no access to credit or savings services, and now do, are not materially better of as a result of it? I think these two conclusions marry up like drunkards in a Las Vegas wedding. Let’s get them across the border to Mexico for an annulment.

Let me conclude this post with two stories. Now, I know David hates stories, but I venture to say he might like one of them. The first was a woman who has been working with FINCA Congo for the past five years. She initially sold shoes, and then, with the income she earned from that and subsequent FINCA loans, she was able to open a second business selling groceries in her home. When I asked her how she rated FINCA’s service, fishing for an answer as to how efficient, responsive, friendly, etc our staff was, she replied: “FINCA has lifted me out of misery and given me my independence.” Wow, sounds suspiciously like empowerment. David would say “No causality!” Rupert would say “Hey,listen to the woman! Maybe she’s not making it up!”

The second story comes from a village bank I met with. I asked the group of women which service they valued most, access to loans or our savings accounts. Again, their answer surprised me: “Savings,” they said in chorus. Why? “Because it is our money.”

Over to you, David.

Tags
Comments

There are 10 comments on “More on the Book of David (Roodman)”:

  • milford bateman on May 4th, 2012 at 9:59 pm said:

    Mr Schofield

    I think its not just econometrics you seem to have problems grasping, but basic economics and logic too.

    By your impeccable logic, if I go to Caesars Palace in Las Vegas and I bump into a couple of jackpot winners – say, poor people who used their scarce funds to get try to hit it big just once in order to escape a life of poverty – then do I find that these success stories are critically important, and do I then make the leap to conclude that gambling must then be having a positive impact on poverty? Of course not! For other obvious reasons (not least the huge profits made in the typical casino), and even though we find some individual success stories, we know for sure that the NET impact of gambling on poverty is always negative.

    Other than to convince those, like yourself, who desperately want to be convinced that microcredit has had a positive impact on the local economy all these years, pointing to a handful of success stories proves absolutely nothing. You can’t just fixate on a few success stories and ignore all the neutrals and the failures, and so also the crucial opportunity costs (what society could have done differently with the microcredit funds). You really do need to look at the NET impact of microcredit at the community level to see if it is having a positive, neutral or negative impact. David is fundamentally correct to claim that the evidence shows that microcredit has historically had no net impact whatsoever on poverty. Better just get over it.



  • milford bateman on May 4th, 2012 at 9:59 pm said:

    Mr Schofield

    I think its not just econometrics you seem to have problems grasping, but basic economics and logic too.

    By your impeccable logic, if I go to Caesars Palace in Las Vegas and I bump into a couple of jackpot winners – say, poor people who used their scarce funds to get try to hit it big just once in order to escape a life of poverty – then do I find that these success stories are critically important, and do I then make the leap to conclude that gambling must then be having a positive impact on poverty? Of course not! For other obvious reasons (not least the huge profits made in the typical casino), and even though we find some individual success stories, we know for sure that the NET impact of gambling on poverty is always negative.

    Other than to convince those, like yourself, who desperately want to be convinced that microcredit has had a positive impact on the local economy all these years, pointing to a handful of success stories proves absolutely nothing. You can’t just fixate on a few success stories and ignore all the neutrals and the failures, and so also the crucial opportunity costs (what society could have done differently with the microcredit funds). You really do need to look at the NET impact of microcredit at the community level to see if it is having a positive, neutral or negative impact. David is fundamentally correct to claim that the evidence shows that microcredit has historically had no net impact whatsoever on poverty. Better just get over it.



  • rupertscofield on May 5th, 2012 at 3:49 pm said:

    Ah, Milford, I was hoping to flush you out at some point. And glad to hear that, instead of comparing microfinance to slinging heroin, it’s now gambling. We’re making progress! But, sorry, you will never convince me that over 150 poor families around the world with microloans are acting against their best interests, and that we pioneers of the movement were victims of mass delusion (or deception) when we saw people leveraging themselves out of poverty through injections of small amounts of capital into environments where previously only the wealthy had access to it. And, believe it or not, donors were also not stupid or tricked into financing it: they put money into because it worked like no other intervenction at the time. This does not mean it is not also true that in saturated markets, where too many microentrepreneurs compete for too few customers, their margins fall to the point where microcredit is not a good investment for them. And we know the bad things that happen when poor people get over indebted. But to conclude as you do that because some MFIs behave irresponsibly we should dismantle the microfinance industry is like saying we should abolish all banks because Lehman Brothers and others misbehaved and created a global financial crisis. But maybe you would say that? And replace them with credit unions?



  • Paul Rippey on May 5th, 2012 at 8:30 am said:

    I found the last paragraph, when you say you are surprised that poor people say they value savings more than credit, deeply depressing. It’s depressing that a prominent person in financial services for the poor would be “surprised”, in 2012, that poor people overwhelmingly are looking for savings in all its forms, often especially commitment savings of some kind, more than credit.

    However, let me not be self-righteous here. I distributed micro loans for a a long time before I really asked people what they wanted, and many of us are guilty of paying more attention to the microcredit juggernaut than to the people we purport to serve. As part of my penance, I helped start savings-revolution dot org, which I hope you lenders will check out.



  • rupertscofield on May 5th, 2012 at 3:36 pm said:

    Good to hear from you, Paul, and glad to see you are still a playah. What surprised was that, given that Congo is such a relatively undeserved market, and that money lenders charge 34% per month for loans from $14 to $100, that the fact that FINCA DRC charges a tenth of that rate was not the primary reason we were attracting clients. But it’s all good: FINCA’s goal has always been to help our clients grow their own capital while making credit available to those who need it.



  • Paul Rippey on May 6th, 2012 at 6:25 pm said:

    Thanks Rupert. That’s good to hear.

    Savings for all, credit for some!

    Stay well,
    Paul



  • milford bateman on May 6th, 2012 at 9:44 pm said:

    Yes, ‘victims of mass delusion’ pretty much sums it up nicely, as I said just recently using the same title…..

    http://column.global-labour-university.org/2012/01/microfinance-delusion.html

    And because you seem to like misrepresenting my views, I guess it’s because you can’t respond otherwise, let me clarify: dismantling support for the microfinance industry is NOT at all like saying that we need to abolish banks, but like saying that we need to abolish all banks that operate like Lehmann Brothers (which is to say most banks on Wall Street). Can you not see the difference?



  • Rupert Scofield on May 12th, 2012 at 1:14 pm said:

    Oh, so you admit that not all banks should be abolished. So would you go so far as to say that not all microfinance banks should be abolished, but only those who behave like SKS in Andar Pradesh, irresponsibly pouring out loans indiscriminately and over indebting clients in a mad race for profit? And that those MFIs that behave responsibly, provide useful services like savings, loans, remittances and microinsurance at a reasonable cost and taking care to understand their clients capacity to repay should escape Bateman’s indiscriminating, ideological scythe.

    Oh, my. I think I win this round. Surely, you noticed?.



  • Daniel Green on May 14th, 2012 at 11:17 am said:

    Point- Scofield (note the lack of “h” in his name, Mr. Bateman). While Mr. Bateman certainly cites compelling research in his article, I fear that the passion with which he and others slam the industry will result in throwing the proverbial baby out with the bathwater.

    Has the 40-year love affair with microcredit gone too far? Probably (judging by recent events in India etc.). Does this trend negate the power of microfinance? I think not.

    I think your critique, Mr. Bateman, would be more effective if you more clearly distinguish between the failures of microcredit vs microfinance as a whole. Responsible deposit taking institutions and savings-led organizations make up much of microfinance, yet you don’t seem to have a problem with them. Or do you….?

    – DG



  • David Roodman on May 8th, 2012 at 9:05 pm said:

    Back at you, Rupert:
    http://blogs.cgdev.org/open_book/2012/05/ripost-to-rupert.php

    I think in your response to Milford, you got at what is probably your real core argument (against me): if 150 million voluntarily partake, how can the movement to build this industry be bad? I do think that’s an argument worth taking seriously because it’s really about respecting the judgment of 150 million people whose lives I hardly understand. Still there is the problem that credit has a certain addictive character, and that human judgment is fallible. I assume the microcredit industry hasn’t caught up with the tobacco industry in number of customers, if you take my point.

    I’m just trying to say that it’s a serious argument but not for me a case-closer.

    –David



Leave a comment

Required fields are marked *. Your email address will not be published.

Please enter the captcha value in the box below. This will prove that you are a human being and not one of those awful spambots! * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.

Updates by email
Updates by email
Receive an email every time something new is posted on my blog
Welcome
Welcome
Welcome to my blog, where I invite you to share in my experience fighting global poverty and working with some of the greatest minds in global economic development. Join me in discovering how we can use social enterprise to create a more equitable, just, and prosperous society.
Listen to my podcast: The Social Enterprise Podcast
Get in touch
Get in touch
Email  Twitter  Linkedin  You Tube